Gujarat Riots: Zakia Jafri's Plea Against Clean Chit To Narendra Modi- Supreme Court Hearing: LIVE UPDATES

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

17 Nov 2021 10:36 AM IST

  • Gujarat Riots: Zakia Jafris Plea Against Clean Chit To Narendra Modi- Supreme Court Hearing: LIVE UPDATES

    Supreme Court will continue hearing today the petition filed by Zakia Jafri challenging the SIT's clean chit to the then Gujarat CM Narendra Modi & other high functionaries in the #GujaratRiots of 2002.A Bench comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and CT Ravikumar is hearing the matter.Yesterday, Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal has drawn the court's attention towards the issue...

    Supreme Court will continue hearing today the petition filed by Zakia Jafri challenging the SIT's clean chit to the then Gujarat CM Narendra Modi & other high functionaries in the #GujaratRiots of 2002.

    A Bench comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and CT Ravikumar is hearing the matter.

    Yesterday, Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal has drawn the court's attention towards the issue of collaboration of the key functionaries of the State with the accused persons, referring to the documents submitted by him along with the Protest Petition. It was his submission that the SIT did not make investigations regarding the collaboration and the allied issues, when there was evidence before it.

    During the course of four days until today, Mr. Sibal contended that the Special Investigation Team had neither looked into the reports by the National Human Rights Commission, Election Commission, or the Committee on Empowerment of Women set up by Parliament with respect to the Gujarat riots nor did they examine the members of such commissions. He also demonstrated the flaw in SIT's stand that there was no violence or arson.

    SIT has not challenged the Gujarat High Court's decision to acquit Maya Kodnani, former BJP MLA from Naroda, who was identified as the 'kingpin' in the Naroda Patiya massacre of 2002 by the trial court, Mr. Kapil Sibal argued hinting at the political optics of the SIT not challenging the High Court order. Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal told the Supreme Court that the SIT head RK Raghavan was appointed as a High Commissioner later, and all these people who 'collaborated were rehabilitated later.

    Stay On This Page For Live Updates From The Hearing

    Live Updates

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:23 PM IST

      Mr. Sibal reads out about the provocative behaviour and mobilisation in that regard

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:23 PM IST

      Sibal: Let me just quickly read pgA of Vol II. Provocative behaviour. This was not looked into by the Mag. and HC.

      Bench: Shouldn't you first take us what is not there in the closure report.

      Bench: Chronology would be what was not dealt with by SIT, Magistrate and then HC.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:20 PM IST

      Bench: Then your main hearing would be withholding of evidence.

      Sibal: I take that point. We'll do that.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:19 PM IST

      Sibal: Now if your lordship goes to the volume itself. I'll quickly go through it.

      Bench: Phone calls are also part of evidence.

      Sibal: With great respect not so. Pandey had withheld call records.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:19 PM IST

      Sibal: Next Tehelka transcript on mass mobilisation, then phone call record, available but not investigated.

      Bench: Tehelka should not be separate heading.

      Sibal: We will provide revise chart.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:19 PM IST

      Sibal: Moving on to Vol II. First heading - Mass mobilisation and hate speech on 27.02.2002. Second heading - Second component of conspiracy - Inaction of policeman and other public officers. Third heading - Attack start much before bodies reached Ahmedabad.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:13 PM IST

      Sibal: We need not quite frankly read this, they have all denied.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:12 PM IST

      Sibal: All these statements were recorded after that. Ashish's statement is before.Khetan's statement is on 27.08.2009.

      Bench: Rest after 01.10.2009?

      Sibal: Yes, all afterwards. All this part of the 188 pg CBI document.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:12 PM IST

      Sibal: Your lordships might note four dates.

      CBI authentication report - 08.05.2009;

      Forwarded to NHRC - 13.05.2009;

      NHRC decided to forward copy to SIT, Gandhinagar - 22.09.2009;

      Forwarded - 01.10.2009.

      They had it from that date.

      Bench: Publication in Tehelka 03.11.2007.

    • 17 Nov 2021 12:11 PM IST

      Bench: We are not on truthfulness of the statements.

      Sibal: I am saying why did the SIT not investigated this.

      Bench: We have noted that, but too much emphasis might not be given on these.

    Next Story