Gujarat Riots: Zakia Jafri's Plea Against Clean Chit To Narendra Modi: LIVE UPDATES From Supreme Court

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

16 Nov 2021 11:04 AM IST

  • Gujarat Riots: Zakia Jafris Plea Against Clean Chit To Narendra Modi: LIVE UPDATES From Supreme Court

    Supreme Court will continue hearing today the petition filed by Zakia Jafri challenging the SIT's clean chit to the then Gujarat CM Narendra Modi & other high functionaries in the #GujaratRiots of 2002.A Bench comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and CT Ravikumar is hearing the matter.During the course of 3 days before today, Mr. Sibal took the bench through the documents...

    Supreme Court will continue hearing today the petition filed by Zakia Jafri challenging the SIT's clean chit to the then Gujarat CM Narendra Modi & other high functionaries in the #GujaratRiots of 2002.

    A Bench comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and CT Ravikumar is hearing the matter.

    During the course of 3 days before today, Mr. Sibal took the bench through the documents to demonstrate the failure of the SIT in investigating the matter and the flaw in SIT's stand that there was no violence or arson. SIT has not challenged the Gujarat High Court's decision to acquit Maya Kodnani, former BJP MLA from Naroda, who was identified as the 'kingpin' in the Naroda Patiya massacre of 2002 by the trial court, Mr. Kapil Sibal argued hinting at the political optics of the SIT not challenging the High Court order. Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal told the Supreme Court that the SIT head RK Raghavan was appointed as a High Commissioner later, and all these people who 'collaborated were rehabilitated later.

    Senior Advocate Kapil Sibal is arguing for the petitioner, Zakia Jafri, widow of Congress MLA Ehsan Jafri who was killed in the Gulberg Housing Society massacre during the 2002 Gujarat Riots. She approached the Supreme Court through a special leave petition challenging the SIT report which ruled out any "larger conspiracy" by high state functionaries in instigating the communal riots following the Godhra massacre.

    Stay On This Page For Live Updates From The Hearing.

    Live Updates

    • 16 Nov 2021 3:09 PM IST

      Bench - Where is the heading?

    • 16 Nov 2021 3:08 PM IST

      Sibal: Milords, why I pointed out these two judgments, is to show judicial direction. Now, let me go back to Vol VA. I have divided two volumes into separate headings. The first heading is arms gathering, bomb manufacturing by organisations all over Guj in 2002.

    • 16 Nov 2021 3:05 PM IST

      Sibal: Innocent should be protected and accused be punished - these are the two elements of Article 21. 

    • 16 Nov 2021 3:01 PM IST

      Sibal: Why am I reading this [judgment]. This is exactly what happened in our case. Provision of CrPC has been violated. You are to collect evidence not accept the statement of the accused. 

    • 16 Nov 2021 2:58 PM IST

      Sibal: What became the ultimate victim in this case was justice itself.

    • 16 Nov 2021 2:58 PM IST

      Sibal: Consider our plight and SIT was filing these in sealed covers till SC said that SIT had to go to the trial court and move ahead. In 2013, we got the full material.

    • 16 Nov 2021 2:57 PM IST

      Sibal:These are not technical omissions. If I may say they are 'deliberate acts' of omission. We had no knowledge that sealed covers were sent by SIT from time to time. We had no access to the sealed covers.

    • 16 Nov 2021 2:57 PM IST

      Sibal: In our case, tapes were not sent by the agency for ascertaining their veracity. NHRC had to move the SC. Why were the prosecuting agencies earlier and SIT not sending the tapes? Acts of commission give colour to the submissions that I am making.

    • 16 Nov 2021 2:52 PM IST

      Sibal: [The Judgment referred to dealt with collusion between doctor and investigating agency; material evidence held from court]

    • 16 Nov 2021 2:49 PM IST

      Sibal: The other judgment that I wanted to show (2012) 8 SCC 263. Some relevance to our case and my submissions.

    Next Story