Breaking: CA Examination: Opt Out Option Will Be With The Candidate, You Have To Respect It: Supreme Court To ICAI [LIVE UPDATES]

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

30 Jun 2021 5:07 AM GMT

Live Updates

30 Jun 2021 6:49 AM GMT
Srinivasan: There has to be a nexus. You need to have some COVID disability.
30 Jun 2021 6:49 AM GMT
Srinivasan: Last time we had given general opt out. 50% or so had suddenly elected to opt out at the last moment. They took advantage. More than 50% simply decided to walk out.
30 Jun 2021 6:49 AM GMT
Bench to Srinivasan: The only thing we will tell you to do is to give the candidates full option to opt out without any conditions.
30 Jun 2021 6:48 AM GMT
Bench to Adgaonkar: You cannot argue that some other institute has done it. You can’t equate two different exams. You can’t keep arguing same points again and again.
30 Jun 2021 6:48 AM GMT
Swaraj: ICAI was reasonable with us with the opt out option.
Bench: At best you can ask for alternate opportunity.
Swaraj: That’s all I’m asking.
30 Jun 2021 6:48 AM GMT
Bench: Institute also has to maintain discipline. You cannot keep expanding the scope.
Adv. Bansuri Swaraj is arguing.
30 Jun 2021 6:46 AM GMT
Arora: My only concern is those candidates who may be found COVID Positive during the exam.
Bench: If it wasn’t for COVID, if you fall sick otherwise, then also you have to give the exams again. You have to treat COVID as any other illness. There is no end to it.
30 Jun 2021 6:45 AM GMT
Arora: I was only on if a candidate doesn’t opt out and then ends up suffering from COVID during exams.
Bench: In the name of COVID, we cannot keep expanding the scope.
30 Jun 2021 6:45 AM GMT
Arora: If you could just allow me to persuade you for half a minute. The students travel, they will take the exams.
Bench: We have said that it would be complete option available to the candidate to opt out or not. If that is there, what else do you want ?
30 Jun 2021 6:45 AM GMT
Bench: Your concern is that even within the city, opt out option should be considered.
Bench: But if Rules require you to appear for the whole exams, we will not interfere with that. We will not tweak with the rules. You will have to take your chance.

Next Updates Previous Updates

Breaking: CA Examination: Opt Out Option Will Be With The Candidate, You Have To Respect It: Supreme Court To ICAI [LIVE UPDATES]

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

Live Updates

Srinivasan: There has to be a nexus. You need to have some COVID disability.

Srinivasan: Last time we had given general opt out. 50% or so had suddenly elected to opt out at the last moment. They took advantage. More than 50% simply decided to walk out.

Bench to Srinivasan: The only thing we will tell you to do is to give the candidates full option to opt out without any conditions.

Bench to Adgaonkar: You cannot argue that some other institute has done it. You can’t equate two different exams. You can’t keep arguing same points again and again.

Swaraj: ICAI was reasonable with us with the opt out option. Bench: At best you can ask for alternate opportunity. Swaraj: That’s all I’m asking.

Bench: Institute also has to maintain discipline. You cannot keep expanding the scope. Adv. Bansuri Swaraj is arguing.

Arora: My only concern is those candidates who may be found COVID Positive during the exam. Bench: If it wasn’t for COVID, if you fall sick otherwise, then also you have to give the exams again. You have to treat COVID as any other illness. There is no end to it.

Arora: I was only on if a candidate doesn’t opt out and then ends up suffering from COVID during exams. Bench: In the name of COVID, we cannot keep expanding the scope.

Arora: If you could just allow me to persuade you for half a minute. The students travel, they will take the exams. Bench: We have said that it would be complete option available to the candidate to opt out or not. If that is there, what else do you want ?

Bench: Your concern is that even within the city, opt out option should be considered.Bench: But if Rules require you to appear for the whole exams, we will not interfere with that. We will not tweak with the rules. You will have to take your chance.

Tags

Swaraj: ICAI was reasonable with us with the opt out option.
Bench: At best you can ask for alternate opportunity.
Swaraj: That’s all I’m asking.

Bench: Institute also has to maintain discipline. You cannot keep expanding the scope.
Adv. Bansuri Swaraj is arguing.

Arora: My only concern is those candidates who may be found COVID Positive during the exam.
Bench: If it wasn’t for COVID, if you fall sick otherwise, then also you have to give the exams again. You have to treat COVID as any other illness. There is no end to it.

Arora: I was only on if a candidate doesn’t opt out and then ends up suffering from COVID during exams.
Bench: In the name of COVID, we cannot keep expanding the scope.

Arora: If you could just allow me to persuade you for half a minute. The students travel, they will take the exams.
Bench: We have said that it would be complete option available to the candidate to opt out or not. If that is there, what else do you want ?

Bench: Your concern is that even within the city, opt out option should be considered.
Bench: But if Rules require you to appear for the whole exams, we will not interfere with that. We will not tweak with the rules. You will have to take your chance.