Breaking: CA Examination: Opt Out Option Will Be With The Candidate, You Have To Respect It: Supreme Court To ICAI [LIVE UPDATES]

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

30 Jun 2021 10:37 AM IST

  • Breaking: CA Examination: Opt Out Option Will Be With The Candidate, You Have To Respect It: Supreme Court To ICAI [LIVE UPDATES]

    A Three Judge Bench of Supreme Court comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and Aniruddha Bose has issued the following directions in the CA Exams matter today.(i) A candidate who has suffered Covid personally or any of his family members, so certified by a registered medical practitioner, as a result of which he is unable to appear for exam, or disabled from preparing for the...

    A Three Judge Bench of Supreme Court comprising Justices AM Khanwilkar, Dinesh Maheshwari and Aniruddha Bose has issued the following directions in the CA Exams matter today.

    (i) A candidate who has suffered Covid personally or any of his family members, so certified by a registered medical practitioner, as a result of which he is unable to appear for exam, or disabled from preparing for the exam, is entitled to exercise the option of opting out. It will not be considered as an attempt. Such candidate will be permitted to appear for the next examination for both old and new syllabus.

    (ii) We make it clear that a candidate need not produce RTPCR report if medical certificate issued by registered medical practitioners for his family members is produced along with request for opting out.

    (iii) As regards candidates affected by lockdown during the relevant period of exam, we are informed that the scheme itself provides that such candidate will be allowed to opt-out and will not be treated as an attempt and such candidate will be allowed to appear in the next examination.

    (iv) As regards the logistical arrangements, both infrastructural and human resources-wise, the ICAI shall ensure that there is strict adherence to the SOP notified by the competent authority, including the Disaster Management Authority.

    (v) It is also clarified if any candidate who is attempting exam gets COVID during exam, he will be allowed to opt out and it will not be treated as an attempt. They can give the exam in the next November cycle. He may be permitted to appear in backup exams as per the rules.

    (vi) In case of last minute change of examination centres, we disapprove the suggestion of ICAI that if it's in the same city, the candidate will not be allowed to opt out. We direct that candidate should be allowed to opt out and it will not be treated us an attempt. Such candidate can appear in backup when situation is conducive".


    Live Updates

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:27 PM IST

      Order: Such candidate shall be permitted to repeat old and new course in 2021 subject to conducive situations.

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:27 PM IST

      Order: Candidates who have suffered personally or family members can be certified by medical practitioner, or for that he is disabled to appear for exam, he should be allowed to opt out and it should not be considered as an attempt.

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:26 PM IST

      Order: Multiple issues were agitated before us. We have confined our consideration to one aspect - comprehensive scheme for opt out.

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:25 PM IST

      Order: Institute has submitted a note. In our opinion, option provided therein is not enough. It needs to be expanded in following terms. 

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:25 PM IST

      Bench: We are not taking your explanation anymore and we are dictating order now. 

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:24 PM IST

      Srinivasan: We will clarify that. Every year we have found that some people come and find the exam difficult and just walk out thinking they have no consequences.

      Bench: Please listen to us.

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:23 PM IST

      Srinivasan: I thought having a medical certificate from any doctor is good enough.

      Bench: Containment zone also.

      Srinivasan: If any person falls in the zone, we will automatically go ahead and allow.

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:23 PM IST

      Bench: If a person has two people who are COVID positive, do you expect him to be able to prepare ? 

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:21 PM IST

      Bench: Both inability and disability both need to be taken into consideration. You have only provided for inability. Yesterday we talked about “COVID related problems”. There could be genuine problems also. You have to look at the situation in present scenario.

    • 30 Jun 2021 12:20 PM IST

      Bench: So far as opt out option is concerned, you have to look at disability as well. He could not be in a position to appear. If it’s COVID related, what is the difficulty ?

    Next Story