Uddhav Thackeray vs Eknath Shinde : Live Updates From Supreme Court | Shiv Sena Case Hearing [February 22]

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

22 Feb 2023 10:08 AM IST

Live Updates

22 Feb 2023 2:54 PM IST
Sibal: Now we're talking of discretion of the governor post the formation of an elected government. If post the formation, 10 people go to the governor, what is his discretion?
22 Feb 2023 2:54 PM IST
Sibal: Under the constitution, there are areas where governor has discretionary powers- subject to three conditions as per Nabam Rebia.
22 Feb 2023 2:54 PM IST
Sibal: Then I come to the governor's decision. Come to Chapter IX. This is an issue that has arisen for the first time.
22 Feb 2023 2:50 PM IST
Sibal: To say that I have 40 members and now I can do what I like and I can remove you- that's unthinkable! He has per se voluntarily given up the membership of the house.
22 Feb 2023 2:43 PM IST
Sibal: The chief whip is the eyes and ears of the leader of the party.
22 Feb 2023 2:42 PM IST
Sibal: He has no choice in the matter. The party will decide. Who is the party? The leader. In finance, who leads the debate in Rajya Sabha - Mr Chidambaram. Who takes the decision? The party.
22 Feb 2023 2:42 PM IST
Sibal: This in essence tells you what the contours of the MLA in the house should be and in what circumstances he can disobey- one, he can take permission of the leader; two, he says something contrary to whip and party condones it.
22 Feb 2023 2:41 PM IST
Sibal: "The membership of the house doesn't become his private property nor can he trade in it." Look at these words. I am sure he wasn't in Assam for cleansing his conscience. There were bigger issues to be dealt with in Assam.
22 Feb 2023 2:41 PM IST
Sibal: You knew the ideology, you knew he was paksh pramukh, you took his ticket, then suddenly you're in Assam and you say you're very worried.
22 Feb 2023 2:33 PM IST
Dr AM Singhvi: A very left leader said that lawyers, doctors- should not be in parliament. We told him- you want parliament to only have unemployed people.

Next Updates Previous Updates

Uddhav Thackeray vs Eknath Shinde : Live Updates From Supreme Court | Shiv Sena Case Hearing [February 22]

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

Live Updates

Sibal: Now we're talking of discretion of the governor post the formation of an elected government. If post the formation, 10 people go to the governor, what is his discretion?

Sibal: Under the constitution, there are areas where governor has discretionary powers- subject to three conditions as per Nabam Rebia.

Sibal: Then I come to the governor's decision. Come to Chapter IX. This is an issue that has arisen for the first time.

Sibal: To say that I have 40 members and now I can do what I like and I can remove you- that's unthinkable! He has per se voluntarily given up the membership of the house.

Sibal: The chief whip is the eyes and ears of the leader of the party.

Sibal: He has no choice in the matter. The party will decide. Who is the party? The leader. In finance, who leads the debate in Rajya Sabha - Mr Chidambaram. Who takes the decision? The party.

Sibal: This in essence tells you what the contours of the MLA in the house should be and in what circumstances he can disobey- one, he can take permission of the leader; two, he says something contrary to whip and party condones it.

Sibal: "The membership of the house doesn't become his private property nor can he trade in it." Look at these words. I am sure he wasn't in Assam for cleansing his conscience. There were bigger issues to be dealt with in Assam.

Sibal: You knew the ideology, you knew he was paksh pramukh, you took his ticket, then suddenly you're in Assam and you say you're very worried.

Dr AM Singhvi: A very left leader said that lawyers, doctors- should not be in parliament. We told him- you want parliament to only have unemployed people.

Tags