"We Come To Court Everyday": Supreme Court Vacation Bench Insists On Lawyers' Physical Presence

"We come to court everyday. Only lawyers who are physically present, we'll give them indulgence," the bench remarked.

The remarks came in cases where Senior Advocate(s) Mukul Rohatgi, AM Singhvi appeared virtually.

When Senior Advocate Mukul Rohatgi appeared virtually, the bench said,

"Why should we grant you any indulgence when you are not in court. Others are here during vacations."

Requesting the bench to adjourn the matter for day after tomorrow, Senior Counsel said,

"Please keep it day after tomorrow. I will be in court."

In another matter wherein Senior Advocate AM Singhvi appeared virtually, the bench said that the vacation was meant not for seniors but for young lawyers.

"Your Lordships may make uniform rule. Let there be no Article 14 exceptions," Singhvi submitted.

"Vacation is meant not for seniors but only for young lawyers," the bench remarked while it asked Senior Counsel as to when he could come to court.

During the course of the day, Advocate K Parameshwar who appeared virtually had referred to May 20, 2022 circular as per which the Registry was directed to provide hybrid options to the Bar/Party in Persons to ensure smooth functioning of the Courts, and requested the court to allow him to argue. However, the bench stood firm and asked the counsel to appear physically.