Supreme Court Issues Directions To Ensure Toilet Facilities In Court Premises For Women, Disabled & Transgender Persons

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

15 Jan 2025 5:26 AM

  • Supreme Court Issues Directions To Ensure Toilet Facilities In Court Premises For Women, Disabled & Transgender Persons

    The Court has asked the States/UTs to allocate sufficient funds for construction and maintenance of toilets in court premises.

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday (January 15) issued a set of directions for the construction of toilet facilities especially for women, specially-abled persons and transgender persons in Court premises and tribunals across the country.A bench comprising Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice R Mahadevan pronounced the judgment in a writ petition filed by Rajeeb Kalita in 2023."We have given...

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday (January 15) issued a set of directions for the construction of toilet facilities especially for women, specially-abled persons and transgender persons in Court premises and tribunals across the country.

    A bench comprising Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice R Mahadevan pronounced the judgment in a writ petition filed by Rajeeb Kalita in 2023.

    "We have given enough number directions for the construction and maintenance of toilets and all other facilities for women, physically disabled persons, transgender persons, etc. The State Governments and of toilets and  Union Territories shall allocate sufficient funds for the construction, maintenance and cleanliness of toilet facilities within the court premises, which shall be periodically reviewed in consultation with a committee constituted by the High Courts. A status report shall be filed by all the States, UTs and High Courts within a period of four months," Justice Mahadevan said while reading out the operative part.

    The following directions were passed in the judgment authored by Justice Mahadevan:

    (i) The High Courts and the State Governments / UTs shall ensure the construction and availability of separate toilet facilities for males, females, PwD, and transgender persons in all Court premises and Tribunals across the Country.

    (ii) The High Courts shall oversee and ensure that these facilities are clearly identifiable and accessible to Judges, advocates, litigants, and court staff.

    (iii) For the aforesaid purpose, a committee shall be constituted in each of the High Courts under the chairmanship of a Judge nominated by the Chief Justice and members comprising the Registrar General/Registrar of the High Court, the Chief Secretary, the PWD Secretary and the Finance Secretary of the State, a representative of the Bar Association and any other officers as they deem it fit, within a period of six weeks.

    (iv) The committee shall formulate a comprehensive plan, carry out the following tasks, and ensure its implementation.

    (a) have a statistic of number of persons visiting the courts every day on an average and ensure that       sufficient separate washrooms are built and maintained.

    (b) conduct a survey regarding the availability of toilet facilities, lacunae in the infrastructure and maintenance of the same. Demarcate existing washrooms and assess the need to convert existing washrooms to meet the requirement of above categories.

    (c) provide alternate facilities like mobile toilets, during construction of new ones, environment friendly toilets (bio-toilets) across the courts as done in Railways.

    (d) Qua women, transgender persons, PwD, provide clear signage and indications along with functional amenities, such as, water, electricity, operational flushes, provision of hand soap, napkins, toilet paper and up to date plumbing systems. Specifically, for PwD washrooms, ensure the installation of ramps and that washrooms are designed to accommodate them.

    (e) conduct a study about maintaining architectural integrity in respect of Heritage Court buildings such as Mumbai, Calcutta, Chennai, etc. To work with the existing facilities by using underutilised spaces to build washrooms, modular solutions to work around the old plumbing systems, engaging professionals to assess the solutions to modernise sanitation facilities.

    (f) effectuate a mandatory cleaning schedule and ensure staffing for maintenance and upkeeping dry bathroom floors along with sensitizing users on clean washroom practices.

    (g) ensure regular maintenance of the toilets by outsourcing professional agencies on contract basis, by employing modern cleaning methods and machinery to ensure better hygiene and usability.

    (h) put in place a mechanism that mandates the periodic inspection of the functionality of these washrooms and specific compliance reports to be filed to a person in-charge.

    (i) frame a complaint / redressal system for speedy reporting of defective washrooms and instant repair of the same.

    (j) ensure that there are working and stocked sanitary pad dispensers in women, PwD, and transgender washrooms.

    (k) nominate or appoint a person specifically in each premises of the High Court/District Court/ Civil Court/Tribunal as nodal officer to monitor the maintenance, address the complaints and communicate with the presiding officer or the appropriate committee; such authority should address the complaints and give standing instructions in writing regarding maintenance and working of the said toilets; and the responsibilities should be fixed.

    (l) have a transparent and separate monetary fund for the construction and maintenance of toilets in court complexes.

    (m) have child safe washrooms in Family court complexes with trained staff equipped to provide children with a safe and hygienic space.

    (n) Provide separate rooms (interconnected with the women's washroom) to cater to nursing mothers' or mothers with infants with feeding stations and changing napkins available. To consider incorporating breastfeeding facilities to support nursing mothers, along with dedicated platforms for changing napkins within toilet areas, similar to the amenities available in airports.

    (o) High Courts to develop and sustain the quality of maintenance can create a grading system for the District Courts and other courts/forums under its supervision, provide certifications and motivate the appropriate officials and staff, which can form part of their service records. 

    (iv) The State Governments / UTs shall allocate sufficient funds for construction, maintenance and cleanliness of the toilet facilities within the court premises, which shall be periodically reviewed in consultation with the committee constituted by the High Courts.

    (v) A status report shall be filed by all the High Courts and the States/UTs within a period of four months. 

    The copy of the judgment has been directed to be forwarded to the Chief Secretaries of all States/UTs and Registrar Generals of High Courts for strict compliance.

    After the judgment was pronounced, Justice Pardiwala orally remarked that contempt action would be taken in case of any default.

    The bench, while reserving judgment in November 2024, had expressed disappointment at the fact that even lady judicial officers were not having private washrooms in many courts.

    In this petition, through an order dated May 8, 2023, the Supreme Court sought the following directions from the High Courts:

    (a) Availability of toilets for men, women and transgenders;

    (b) Steps taken for maintenance of toilets;

    (c) Whether separate toilet facilities are made available to litigants, lawyers and judicial officers; and

    (d) Whether adequate facilities for sanitary napkins dispensers are made available in women's toilets.

    Also from the judgment- Supreme Court Bemoans Lack Of Toilet Facilities In HCs & District Judiciary, Says Access To Justice Impacted By Neglect Of Sanitation Needs

    Case Details: RAJEEB KALITA v UNION OF INDIA AND ORS.W.P.(C) No. 538/2023

    Citation : 2025 LiveLaw (SC) 72

    Click here to read the judgment 



    Next Story