Plea To Cancel NEET-UG 24 : Supreme Court Poses Queries To Centre & NTA- Live Updates (July 18)

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

18 July 2024 7:00 AM IST

  • Plea To Cancel NEET-UG 24 : Supreme Court Poses Queries To Centre & NTA- Live Updates (July 18)

    The Supreme Court will hear today petitions seeking to cancel the NEET-UG 2024 test held on May 5 over alleged paper leak and malpractices..A bench comprising Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud, Justices JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra will hear the matter post 10.30 AM. The NEET matters are listed as items 5 to 9.The Central Government and the National Testing Agency have opposed the demand...

    The Supreme Court will hear today petitions seeking to cancel the NEET-UG 2024 test held on May 5 over alleged paper leak and malpractices..

    A bench comprising Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud, Justices JB Pardiwala and Manoj Misra will hear the matter post 10.30 AM. The NEET matters are listed as items 5 to 9.

    The Central Government and the National Testing Agency have opposed the demand for re-test by stating that the malpractices are localised and have not affected the sanctity of the entire exam. The Centre cited a data analytics report prepared by IIT Madras to argue that there was no systemic failure as the report did not indicate any "mass malpractice".

    During the hearing held on July 8, the bench led by CJI DY Chandrachud sought the responses of the Union/NTA on the extent of the paper leak and possible segregation of the wrongdoers from others. The Court said that if the sanctity of the entire exam has been affected and it was impossible to separate the beneficiaries of fraud from the honest candidates, then a re-test may be necessary. The Court also said that the re-test would be the last option, considering the impact on nearly 24 lakh students.

    Follow this page for live updates from today's hearing.

     

    Live Updates

    • 18 July 2024 12:45 PM IST

      CJI : As matter stands now, 61 students get 720/720, out of whom 44 are students who got extra marks for the two correct options for a question. So the number really is 17..

    • 18 July 2024 12:45 PM IST

      NTA counsel says that the 44 were given marks for the questions having one extra answer as per NCERT booklet.

    • 18 July 2024 12:45 PM IST

      CJI : 67 students who secured 720/720...

      SG : That is reduced after re-exam..

      CJI : How many of them were in 1563?

      NTA : 44

    • 18 July 2024 12:42 PM IST

      CJI : Out of top hundred, AP got seven, Bihar seven, Gujarat seven, Haryana four, Delhi three, Karnataka 6, Kerala 5, Maharashtra 5, TN 8, UP 6, WB 5...So it appears that the spread in the top hundred marks is distributed across the country, 12 states and one UT.

      SG : First 100 rankers are spread across 95 centres located in 56 cities within 18 States/UTs.

    • 18 July 2024 12:39 PM IST

      Hooda : In the first instance, they indulged in pick and choose to identify 15063. One classic example is Bahadurgarh. And they got a chance to appear again!

      CJI : Out of that how many make it to one lakh eight thousand?

      Hooda : That is an interesting question that they have not answered.

      CJI : We will ask.

    • 18 July 2024 12:38 PM IST

      Hooda : To hush up the matter, they have a re-exam.

      CJI : Mr.Hooda, that issue has attained finality. This Court has upheld the re-examination.

    • 18 July 2024 12:38 PM IST

      Hooda : They have not come clean on that. First they said there was delay in distribution. When they were caught, then they said we are having a re-exam and don't go into the issue of grace marks. The question who they gave grace marks to 15063 odd people has not been examined by this court.

    • 18 July 2024 12:37 PM IST

      Hooda : Entire country was given paper from SBI but in Hardayal school paper from Canara bank was given. The principal says that the instruction was that let the students do Canara bank paper. They gave grace marks to everyone in the school. Because of that extra marks, 6 people got 720/720, two people from the same centre got 718.

    • 18 July 2024 12:34 PM IST

      Hooda : One Hardayal School from Bahadurgarh has a special story...there were 6 people...What happened in Bahadurgarh is glaring. NTA never disclosed that the question paper taken from Canara bank was distributed. There was no delay. The principal of school is on record that they collected papers from SBI and Canara Bank and that the.

      SG : That is a different issue...

      Hooda : Allow me to say...they are getting agitated..

    • 18 July 2024 12:33 PM IST

      SG : The purpose is to show that the toppers are spread over. Just to show that and that there is no abnormal spike in any particular centre.

    Next Story