LIVE-UPDATES - Kashmir Petitions

Radhika Roy

14 Nov 2019 11:18 AM IST

Live Updates

14 Nov 2019 12:53 PM IST
Sibal refering to case laws submits that the court must look into these questions to determine how 19 can be restricted-
Was it necessary? Was it reasonable?
14 Nov 2019 12:42 PM IST
Sibal : They say you need prior permission to move in case of an emergency. How do I take that permission if I can't move out of my house, to even make a telephone call?
14 Nov 2019 12:38 PM IST
J Gavai- so it's a curfew?
KS- that's what I've been saying. It's complete prohibition, not restriction.
14 Nov 2019 12:38 PM IST
Sibal refers to govt affidavit and informs court that no public movement is allowed. Usually in 144, not more than 5 people can gather. Here govt has stated that "there shall be no movement of public
14 Nov 2019 12:32 PM IST
J Reddy- as per the order of Aug 5, what do you think should have been banned to maintain public order?
Sibal : Block social media. WhatsApp, Facebook, Instagram etc. They indulge in gossip mongering. They spread fake news. But you cannot interfere with landlines and emails. Social media is a platform for mass communication
14 Nov 2019 12:31 PM IST
Sibal : :My submission is that they have passed orders which aren't in accordance with 5(2) and that cannot be the way in which you restrict my fundamental right to speech and expression
14 Nov 2019 12:24 PM IST
Sibal :Govt order is not in accordance with provisions of Telegraph Act. Power is restricted under 5(2)
14 Nov 2019 12:23 PM IST
Sibal : 144 orders passed without justification. No consideration for peace loving people
14 Nov 2019 12:16 PM IST
Sibal : They say there are no restrictions in 99% of Kashmir. We do not accept that, when we know the facts are something different
14 Nov 2019 12:16 PM IST
Sibal- essential services have been stopped completely. How do I get a money transfer from the bank?

>Load More

LIVE-UPDATES - Kashmir Petitions

Radhika Roy

Live Updates

Sibal refering to case laws submits that the court must look into these questions to determine how 19 can be restricted- Was it necessary? Was it reasonable?

Sibal : They say you need prior permission to move in case of an emergency. How do I take that permission if I can't move out of my house, to even make a telephone call?

J Gavai- so it's a curfew?KS- that's what I've been saying. It's complete prohibition, not restriction.

Sibal refers to govt affidavit and informs court that no public movement is allowed. Usually in 144, not more than 5 people can gather. Here govt has stated that "there shall be no movement of public

Sibal : :My submission is that they have passed orders which aren't in accordance with 5(2) and that cannot be the way in which you restrict my fundamental right to speech and expression

Sibal :Govt order is not in accordance with provisions of Telegraph Act. Power is restricted under 5(2)

Sibal : 144 orders passed without justification. No consideration for peace loving people

Sibal : They say there are no restrictions in 99% of Kashmir. We do not accept that, when we know the facts are something different

Sibal- essential services have been stopped completely. How do I get a money transfer from the bank?

Tags

Sibal refering to case laws submits that the court must look into these questions to determine how 19 can be restricted-
Was it necessary? Was it reasonable?

J Gavai- so it's a curfew?
KS- that's what I've been saying. It's complete prohibition, not restriction.