Karnataka Hijab Ban: Supreme Court Hearing DAY-4 -LIVE UPDATES

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

12 Sept 2022 1:07 PM IST

  • Karnataka Hijab Ban: Supreme Court Hearing DAY-4 -LIVE UPDATES

    Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia will hear a batch of petitions challenging the ban on wearing Hijab in educational institutions in Karnataka.A batch of 23 petitions is listed before the bench. Some of them are writ petitions filed directly before the Supreme Court seeking the right to wear hijab for Muslim girl students. Some others are special...

    Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia will hear a batch of petitions challenging the ban on wearing Hijab in educational institutions in Karnataka.

    A batch of 23 petitions is listed before the bench. Some of them are writ petitions filed directly before the Supreme Court seeking the right to wear hijab for Muslim girl students. Some others are special leave petitions which challenge the judgment of the Karnataka High Court dated March 15 which upheld the hijab ban.

    So far, the bench has heard Senior Advocate Devadatt Kamat for the petitioners who argued that the Government Order, banning Hijabs in educational institutions violates students' fundamental rights under Article 19, 21 and 25 of the Constitution.

    During the course of hearing, the bench has also raised several queries like whether religious clothing can be worn in a government run institution in a secular country. The bench also asked the counsels whether if it is held that freedom of expression includes the freedom to dress, would it also include the freedom to undress?

    The SLPs has been filed against the judgment dated March 15 passed by the High Court of Karnataka, upholding Government Order dated 05.02.2022, which has effectively prohibited Petitioners, and other such female Muslim students from wearing the headscarf in their Pre-University Colleges. A Full Bench of the High Court comprising Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi, Justice Krishna Dixit and Justice JM Khazi held that wearing of hijab by women was not an essential religious practice of Islam. The Bench further held the prescription of uniform dress code in educational institutions was not violative of the fundamental rights of the petitioners.

    FOLLOW LIVE UPDATES HERE:

    Live Updates

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:22 PM IST

      Mucchala : Whether right to privacy and right to freedom of expression and right to practice religion are mutually exclusive or supplement each other.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:21 PM IST

      Mucchala : But I have mentioned certain other points - whether right to freedom of right to education are mutually agnostic? Does the doctrine of essential religious practice apply to right claimed under Art 25(1).

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:21 PM IST

      Mucchala : I would like to point out to the preliminary objection that the matter should be referred to the Constitution Bench. On this my learned friend Mr.Kamat has made submissions, which I will not repeat.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:17 PM IST

      Justice Gupta :We can only take into account the averments made before the High Court.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:17 PM IST

      Mucchala : See the averments in the SLP...

      J Gupta : What is your argument?

      Mucchala : We have given instances of denial of entry for people for wearing hijab. This is denial of access of education.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:15 PM IST

      Muchhala : It is astonishing that the learned judges of the High Court held that there were no pleadings.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:14 PM IST

      Mucchala continues reading from the petition, showing the bench pleadings regarding hijab - "...previous students since several years have continued to wear hijab without any hindrance".

      "There is no denial of this by the respondent", Muchhala.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:11 PM IST

      Mucchala reads out from the petition - "It is submitted that petitioners conscientiously believe that hijab is a part of their religion..."...

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:08 PM IST

      Mucchala : I draw your lordships attention to paragraphs...which will make it sufficiently clear that the findings of the learned judges that there are no pleadings regarding wearing of hijab are wrong.

    • 12 Sept 2022 2:08 PM IST

      Sr Adv Yusuf Muchchala starts by saying that the High Court finding that there are no pleadings in petition as to when the students started wearing Hijab is wrong.

    Next Story