Article 370 Case : Live Updates From Supreme Court [Day 15]

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

4 Sept 2023 10:25 AM IST

  • Article 370 Case : Live Updates From Supreme Court [Day 15]

    A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court will resume hearing today the respondents' arguments in the batch of petitions challenging the dilution of Article370 of the Constitution.Follow this page for live...

    A Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court will resume hearing today the respondents' arguments in the batch of petitions challenging the dilution of Article370 of the Constitution.

    Follow this page for live updates.

    Live Updates

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:30 PM IST

      Sibal: So far, the proviso has never been interpreted in the fashion that they're seeking to interpret

      Justice Khanna: That occassion never arose

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:29 PM IST

      CJI: But that's not there in the proviso.

      Sibal: It is

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:26 PM IST

      CJI: To accept your argument, we will have to read a further condition in the proviso that the recommendation of the Constituent Assembly has to be in the same terms as the action proposed to be taken by the President.

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:24 PM IST

      CJI: What is that an indicator of? That whatever is happening there is really the incorporation of what is happening in union of India.

      Sibal: I can only say that either we interpret 370(3) in its text and context or find something that is not there.

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:23 PM IST

      CJI: Except for the provision for permanent residents - section 6, which finds its mirror image in Art 35A, every other provision was a mirror image of the Indian Constitution.

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:19 PM IST

      Sibal: First the recommendation will come, then you'll pass the order. You can't reverse the order.

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:17 PM IST

      Sibal: Your lordships aren't here to tell them what the way out of this is. The way out is a political process, or some other process. That's for them to see.

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:16 PM IST

      Sibal: Can anyone even think about this? That constituent assembly, drafting the constitution of J&K, saying that they're integral part of India- will say that the day we're not in place, abrogate it because there's a plenary power superior in 370, which is not even there in 370

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:13 PM IST

      Sibal: It is the council of ministers that will decide, not the parliament. It was to ensure that there was slow integration of J&K to India through a process that was easy, through a process that allows executives to communicate with each other.

    • 4 Sept 2023 3:11 PM IST

      Sibal: It is a limitation on parliament to make laws. It stares you in the face and you're talking about plenary power. Where's the plenary power?

    Next Story