Perjury Case: SC Asks Ex-BCCI Chief Anurag Thakur To Tender Fresh Apology

In further trouble for former BCCI President Anurag Thakur, the Supreme Court today rejected his apology in the perjury case and also asked him to be personally present before it on July 14.

Two months after he was issued a contempt notice for filing some false statements and affidavit in the Lodha panel Vs BCCI case, Thakur had on March 6 appeared personally before the bench and tendered an unconditional and unqualified apology.

A bench led by Justice Deepak Misra told Additional Solicitor General PS Patwalia, who appeared for the BJP MP:"No We are not happy with the nature, the tone and tenor of the affidavit (of apology)... it has to be categorical. He should file a fresh affidavit by Wednesday... ask him to remain present on July 14,"

The bench headed by then Chief Justice T S Thakur had on January 2 removed BCCI President Anurag Thakur and Secretary Ajay Shirke for continued defiance regarding implementation of Lodha panel reforms.

Anurag Thakur was in deeper trouble as the bench also issued show cause notice wherein he is to explain why perjury and contempt proceedings shall not be initiated against him for making certain false statements on oath before the court.

“When there was ample proof of it on record, he had in an affidavit filed on oath denied the same before the court which the bench said amounted to perjury.The bench found that Anurag had asked Shashank Manohar, the Chairman of the ICC to write a letter to the BCCI that the appointment of a CAG would tantamount to government interference in the working of the BCCI.

It is to be noted that while objecting to the Lodha panel’s recommendation to include a CAG nominee within the BCCI to bring in "transparency and oversight in monitoring the finances", the Board had been consistently taking the ground that inclusion of a CAG nominee would bring in an element of government interference in board affairs, which under ICC rules was a ground for its de-recognition or suspension. Interestingly, Manohar in an affidavit admitted that Anurag had written a letter to him in this regard but he had refused saying that the Supreme Court had already taken a stand on appointment of CAG.

“We prima facie feel that you (Anurag Thakur) are in contempt and we also prima facie feel that you are liable for perjury and we are inclined to launch prosecution. Manohar is very clear. You did ask him to write a letter from ICC that CAG nominee in BCCI would affect the autonomy of the board and then you denied it in an affidavit filed before the court. This means you have made a false statement on oath. Once we pronounce the order, your client may have nowhere to go except to jail” then CJI Thakur had told  Thakur’s lawyer.