Business Of Selling Fruits In Small Sheds Not Large Scale Commercial Activity, Govt Land Can Be Allotted Without Public Auction: Gujarat High Court

The Gujarat High Court has recently come to the rescue of small vegetable sellers by setting aside the notice of the Collector, asking them to vacate a government land for construction of a Police station.

The Court rejected the ground stated by the Collector that petitioners request for allotment of land cannot be acceded without public auction, because they are carrying on commercial purpose. It observed,

"petitioners are doing small business like that of selling of vegetables / fruits, etc. by keeping small sheds and lorries. Therefore, if that activities are considered, it cannot be termed as large scale commercial activities and, therefore, if the vocation of the petitioners are considered then it is of small retail business then the other government lands can be considered for allotment of appropriate portion of land, available in the vicinity to the petitioners."

The order is subject to petitioners paying the requisite price thereof, as may be decided by the Government in accordance with the law.

The Bench comprising Justice AP Thaker was hearing a petition wherein the Petitioners were poor persons and doing their businesses in sheds and small shops by keeping lorries on the piece of land. They were also paying market rate to the Panchayat along with other bills. However, it was contested that the piece of land was Government land which was allotted to a police station in 2008. Subsequently, the Petitioners were issued several notices were issued by the authorities to remove their sheds and shops.

Accordingly, the Petitioners the Special Civil Application challenging these notices in 2019. They also made detailed representations but before the representations could be adjudicated on, the police authorities demolished all sheds and shops and lorries.