Allahabad HC Seeks Action Taken Report Against Govt Medical College Principal For Making Communally Laced Remarks Against Muslims[Read Order]

A division bench comprised by Chief Justice Govind Mathur and Justice S D Singh has granted two weeks time to the Standing Counsel to seek instructions and has posted the matter for hearing on July 20.

The order has been passed in a PIL filed by Delhi-based organization, Indian Muslim for Progress and Reforms (IMPAR), through Advocate Sayyed Kashif Abbas Rizvi, seeking penal action against Lalchandani, in addition to suspension from the Government post.

On May 31, 2020, a sting-operated video clip went viral on Internet where Lalchandani can be seen stereotyping the entire Muslim community as 'terrorists' and agreeing to kill all the Muslim patients by administering (poisonous) injections in them.

Calling out the "venomous misconduct" on part of a Government employee, the Petitioner has sought strict action against Lalchandani for instigating her listeners to "medically, socially and economically discriminate" against a particular religious community in India.

"This is a clear misconduct on part of a senior government servant and a medical doctor who has made communally-laced remarks. In the same conversation, she also accuses government of 'sacrificing' 100 Crore people for the sake of 30 Crore people!

That an evident anti-Muslim bigotry by a senior medical professional working in a Government Hospital is unfounded and having potential to compromise with delivery of even basic healthcare to vulnerable patients belonging to a particular religious community," the plea states.

The Petitioner has contended that Lalchandani's conduct prima facie violates various provisions of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and the Code of Medical Ethics Regulation, 2002, apart from various Constitutional principles.

The plea therefore seeks the following reliefs against propagation of "hate speech":

• Direct the authorities to suspend Lalchandani from the post of Principal, GSVM Medical College, Kanpur and initiate Disciplinary Proceedings against her;
• Direct the authorities to take penal action against Lalchandani under Section(s) 153A, 295A, 298, IPC and Section 54 of the Disaster Management Act, 2005;
• Direct the Medical Council of India to condemn the act of and to initiate de-registration proceedings against Lalchandani and further to frame specific guidelines to check into the menace of religious bigotry among medical professionals.

Case Details:

Case Title: Indian Muslims for Progress And Reforms (IMPAR) v. Union of India & Ors.

Case No.: PIL No. 682/2020

Quorum: Chief Justice Govind Mathur and Justice S D Singh

Appearance: Advocate Sayyed Kashif Abbas Rizvi (for Petitioner); Standing Counsel Avanish Mishra (for State)

Click Here To Download Order

Read Order