CJI: thats the correctness which falls for determination....once notified all the subclasses comprise one single group of SCs and therefore since it is one composite group of SCs, if you get reservation in state you give it to all of them.

Nafde: that is inconsistent with article 15(4) and 16(4). These are enabling provisions . I divide the list of legislative competence intow 2 groups 1. the power to a particular SC under 341 ... 341 is merely a fetter to identify a particular caste as SC and it stops there.