Hijab Ban- Karnataka High Court Full Bench Hearing (Day 8)- LIVE UPDATES

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

22 Feb 2022 2:07 PM IST

  • Hijab Ban- Karnataka High Court Full Bench Hearing (Day 8)- LIVE UPDATES

    Karnataka High Court Full Bench will continue hearing on a batch of petitions challenging the hijab ban in educational institutions.The matter is before a bench comprising Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi, Justice Krishna S Dixit and Justice JM Khazi will hear the petitions today at 2.30 PM.On Monday, Chief Justice sought a clarification from the State regarding its stand on banning hijab....

    Karnataka High Court Full Bench will continue hearing on a batch of petitions challenging the hijab ban in educational institutions.

    The matter is before a bench comprising Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi, Justice Krishna S Dixit and Justice JM Khazi will hear the petitions today at 2.30 PM.

    On Monday, Chief Justice sought a clarification from the State regarding its stand on banning hijab. This arose in view of the AG's submission that the Government Order dated February 5, which has been challenged in the writ petitions, does not prescribe any ban on hijab and that it is only an "innocuous" order which asks students to follow the uniforms prescribed by their institutions.

    "What is your stand?Whether hijab can be permitted in institutions or not?", the Chief Justice raised a pointed query.

    "The operative portion of the GO leaves it to the institutions", the AG submitted.

    "If institutions permit hijab, you have objections?", the CJ asked further

    "If the institutions are to permit, we would possibly take a decision as and when the issue arises...", the AG responded.

    "You have to take a stand", the CJI reiterated.

    "My answer is that we have not prescribed anything. The Order , it gives complete autonomy to institution to decide uniform. Whether students be allowed to wear dress or apprarel which could be symbol of religion, the stand of the state is.. element of introducing religious dress should not be there in uniform. As a matter of principle, the answer is in preamble of Karnataka Education Act which is to foster secular environment", the AG replied.

    FOLLOW THE LIVE UPDATES HERE

    Live Updates

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:55 PM IST

      AG : According to me that arguments is mutually destructive to argument of Article 25. If their argument accepted, persons who do not want to wear hijab will have the right to not wear also. It would mean there is element of option.

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:54 PM IST

      AG : G: Lordhsips must have noticed one argument of petition. They say they trace their right independently to Article 19 (1) (a)..to wear the right as a free expression..

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:52 PM IST

      Justice Dixit: What you mean to say it should be very focal to the religion?

      AG: Yes ,fundamental to the religion.

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:52 PM IST

      AG : What is optional is not compulsory; What is not compulsory is not obligatory; What is not obligatory is not essential.

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:51 PM IST

      AG : I read this judgment (Qureshi) to show that it has said reading of Quran has shown that sacrifice of cow on that day is not obligatory. The very fact of an option seems to run counter to an obligatory duty.

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:51 PM IST

      AG : It is for the petitioners to demonstrate beyond doubt as to what is compulsory to be followed. During the course of hearing, court asked petitioners, what is obligatory and what is optional. I feel it is for them to satisfy your lordships.

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:50 PM IST

      AG: I have cited this judgement to drive home the point...

      Justice Dixit : ...on pleadings being insufficient.

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:49 PM IST

      AG quotes from Qureshi case : "We have, however, no material on the record before us which will enable us to say, in the face of the foregoing facts, that the sacrifice of a cow on that day is an obligatory overt act for a Mussalman to exhibit his religious belief and idea"

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:48 PM IST

      AG quotes from Qureshi case : "We have no affidavit before us by any Maulana explaining the implications of those Verses or throwing any light on this problem".

    • 22 Feb 2022 2:47 PM IST

      AG quotes from Qureshi case : "No affidavit has been filed by any person specially competent to expound the relevant tenets of Islam. 'No reference 'is made in the petition to any particular Surah of the Holy Quran which, in terms, requires the sacrifice of a cow".

    Next Story