Same Sex Marriage- Supreme Court Constitution Bench Hearing-DAY-2- LIVE UPDATES

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

19 April 2023 4:47 AM GMT

  • Same Sex Marriage- Supreme Court Constitution Bench Hearing-DAY-2- LIVE UPDATES

    A constitution bench of Supreme Court will continue hearing batch of petitions seeking legal recognition for same-sex marriage in India.On the first day of the hearings in the batch of petitions seeking legal recognition for same-sex marriage in India, the primary arguments raised before the Constitution bench of the Supreme Court pertained to marriage being a way to help assimilate...

    A constitution bench of Supreme Court will continue hearing batch of petitions seeking legal recognition for same-sex marriage in India.

    On the first day of the hearings in the batch of petitions seeking legal recognition for same-sex marriage in India, the primary arguments raised before the Constitution bench of the Supreme Court pertained to marriage being a way to help assimilate queer individuals in the society better and end stigma against them.

    The matter was heard by a bench comprising CJI DY Chandrachud, Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, Justice Ravindra Bhat, Justice Hima Kohli, and Justice PS Narasimha. 

    Follow this thread for live updates.

    Live Updates

    • 19 April 2023 6:24 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: This Victorian morality issue came in 1800s. If you go back to Indian texts, for hundreds of years, these acts (homosexuality) were depicted on walls for thousands of years. That remained the concept of morality.

    • 19 April 2023 6:24 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: Things change when the moral authority of an institution says that look through the prism of gender neutrality.

    • 19 April 2023 6:24 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: In the US also, a large part of the society is also very conservative. In the recent past, they have gone back on abortions! It's not that they're very much ahead- the red necks as they're called. They're very conservative.

    • 19 April 2023 6:19 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: Kindly read the conclusion in Navtej- "If this (decriminalizing homosexuality) is the first step is the affirmative steps remain." The prayers I seek are affirmative steps which will help me lead a dignified life.

    • 19 April 2023 6:19 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: In Navtej, the Centre's affidavit said, "we leave it to the court". But the court commented on it in Navtej- that we wish you would have taken a stand. So it's not a matter of grace that oh we leave it to you.

    • 19 April 2023 6:14 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: Please see this from Nepal- this is definitely not a case of "urban elitism".

    • 19 April 2023 6:14 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: In my case, the ceremony was conducted by the parents ten years ago. They also went through some transformation. They had a reception. They were from a small home town. Some people go abroad and marry. 

    • 19 April 2023 6:09 AM GMT

      (Adv Arundhati Katju says something to Rohatgi)

      Rohatgi: Our parents have by and large accepted us. We've gone through the process with our parents. They want them to settle, have a family, have the same recognition.

    • 19 April 2023 6:08 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: We rely on the prestige and the moral authority of the court apart from Article 141. When the highest court of the land says that you have a right to marry, that is what will drive the society to accept this group.

    • 19 April 2023 6:07 AM GMT

      Rohatgi: Here, we need to push the society to acknowledge us as equals in all respects because the constitution says so. This court enjoys moral authority and public confidence.

    Next Story