Karnataka Hijab Ban: Supreme Court Hearing DAY-4 -LIVE UPDATES

LIVELAW NEWS NETWORK

12 Sept 2022 1:07 PM IST

  • Karnataka Hijab Ban: Supreme Court Hearing DAY-4 -LIVE UPDATES

    Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia will hear a batch of petitions challenging the ban on wearing Hijab in educational institutions in Karnataka.A batch of 23 petitions is listed before the bench. Some of them are writ petitions filed directly before the Supreme Court seeking the right to wear hijab for Muslim girl students. Some others are special...

    Supreme Court bench comprising Justices Hemant Gupta and Sudhanshu Dhulia will hear a batch of petitions challenging the ban on wearing Hijab in educational institutions in Karnataka.

    A batch of 23 petitions is listed before the bench. Some of them are writ petitions filed directly before the Supreme Court seeking the right to wear hijab for Muslim girl students. Some others are special leave petitions which challenge the judgment of the Karnataka High Court dated March 15 which upheld the hijab ban.

    So far, the bench has heard Senior Advocate Devadatt Kamat for the petitioners who argued that the Government Order, banning Hijabs in educational institutions violates students' fundamental rights under Article 19, 21 and 25 of the Constitution.

    During the course of hearing, the bench has also raised several queries like whether religious clothing can be worn in a government run institution in a secular country. The bench also asked the counsels whether if it is held that freedom of expression includes the freedom to dress, would it also include the freedom to undress?

    The SLPs has been filed against the judgment dated March 15 passed by the High Court of Karnataka, upholding Government Order dated 05.02.2022, which has effectively prohibited Petitioners, and other such female Muslim students from wearing the headscarf in their Pre-University Colleges. A Full Bench of the High Court comprising Chief Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi, Justice Krishna Dixit and Justice JM Khazi held that wearing of hijab by women was not an essential religious practice of Islam. The Bench further held the prescription of uniform dress code in educational institutions was not violative of the fundamental rights of the petitioners.

    FOLLOW LIVE UPDATES HERE:

    Live Updates

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:47 PM IST

      Khurshid : I will wear the prescribed uniform. But the question is if I can wear anything more which is important for my culture.

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:46 PM IST

      Khurshid : Qualified public space may hold good in some places. If I am in the Army, I have to wear the prescribed uniform. If I am a member of Bar Council, I have to wear the prescribed uniform.

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:41 PM IST

      Khurshid : The idea of unity in diversity comes from this preservation of composite culture.

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:37 PM IST

      Khurshid addressing the court on the issue of "qualified public spaces". Says HC has quoted Fundamental Duty under Article 51A(h) ( promotion of scientific temper..). But HC ingored 51A(f) which speaks of preserving "composite culture".

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:35 PM IST

      Khurshid : In America, there are conscientious objectors, who are treated one way or other. Muhammad Ali was a great boxer who was a conscientious objector against Vietnam war and he had to face prison

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:31 PM IST

      Khurshid : Conscience has to be a single person's. 

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:29 PM IST

      Khurshid explains to the bench the differences between burqa, jilbab, hijab.

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:28 PM IST

      Justice Gupta : With due respect, we will not like to keep the Holy Book. You may give us the print outs of the relevant verses.

      Khurshid : It can go to the judges' library.

      J Gupta : Judges library has a copy.

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:28 PM IST

      Khurshid : Our jurisprudence recognizes culture as well as religion. Since your lordships have been addressed on essential religious practice, I will not elaborate. 

    • 12 Sept 2022 3:25 PM IST

      Justice Dhulia : What is your view? Is it an essential religious practice?

      Khurshid : It can be seen as religion, can be seen as conscience, can be seen as culture, can be seen as individual dignity and privacy.

    Next Story