Sibal : Scheme of the constitution is clear, 341 , it is meant to identify heterogeneity of those communities, castes or tribes which have been dehumanized over centuries . the power of reservation is found in 16(4)

Nath J : is there nay state in which under article 330 , reservations are made specifying the communities included in SC based upon their population or so, ex Valmikis are 5 seat etc

Gavai J : as a matter of fact even an SC from Punjab can contest an election in Maharashtra

Sibal : that is right, because when we talk about reservation we talk about education and employment not representation...