Kar AG : In Maneka Gandhi case, it was held since she did not say why she wanted to travel abroad, impounding of passport will not violate Article 19.

Kar AG from Maneka Gandhi : If a preacher wants to go abroad and his passport is impounded, his Article 19(1)(a) is violated. If a journalist's passport is impounded, his 19(1)(a) right is violated. But since Maneka Gandhi did not say why she wanted to go, it was held there is no