Farasat : 1. Chinnaiah is internally contradicted because it says that article 341 is solely for the purpose of reservation alone; 2. Article 342A has been introduced in the constitution and that read with the judgement in Jaishree patil completely negates the fundamental logic of chinnaiah; 3. in so far as efficiency in service under Article 335 is concerned, that is something when read in context of the constitution in fact supports subclassification, doesn't negate it .