Punjab AG : the brithmark philosphy that once you are born in SC family you become an SC, doesn't apply in 341 2 reasons why- 1. you have the benefit of the schedule only if you are within the definitions by the orders of the president as ascribed by the parliament; 2. why is not a monolithic because it is a reversible process, today you say that caste is schedule caste in 3 districts of Punjab, tomorrow you may say reverse that status for one of three districts also.