CJI: Just one caveat- we are not here on the challenge to the legality of a law providing for corporate donations per se. Wider issue is not that... because 293 already allows that.

CJI: The latter part- without consent and consultation is considered.

Sibal: This is what I'm saying.

CJI: The moment we accepted 293, our society legitimised corporate quit pro quo. There is an element of qui pro quo the moment you have a corporation...the large public limited company who makes a donation doesn't give it for charity.