A P Singh : “Vinay was residing in a cluster of jhuggis (8 by 8 feet) at Ravidas Camp. The economic condition of the families of the prisoners were not a part of the note presented.”

Singh cites the case of SP Gupta v. Union of India.

He states that the aspect of “Advice tendered by the Council of Ministers to the President” could not be exercised because elections were going on at that time.