Justice Chandrachud : We will say supply of oxygen, projected need of states, the basis of allocation of oxygen from central pool, the methodology adopted to communicate requirement of states on a dynamic basis.
Supreme Court tentatively highlights the following issues :
1. Supply of oxygen - The Centre should apprise the current total availability of oxygen...
Solicitor General intervenes - I would request your lordship to avoid for a good reason. It is being augmented.
Supreme Court :During national crisis, Supreme Court cannot be a mute spectator. The role of the Supreme Court is complimentary in nature. The issues which travails state boundaries is what this court will look into and thus Article 32 jurisdiction has been assumed. #COVID19
Supreme Court : It is in that spirit that the Supreme Court has assumed jurisdiction suo moto under Article 32. Therefore, we clarify that the High Courts need not be restrained from dealing with the issues.
#SupremeCourt #COVID19 #Oxygen
Supreme Court : But the intervention of this Supreme Court must be understood in the correct perspective.
There are some issues which transcend the regional boundaries.
#SupremeCourt #COVID19 #Oxygen
Supreme Court : High Courts are best situated to make an assessment of ground realities in each states and find flexible solutions for the problems faced by citizens.
Therefore, we see no reason or justification to interdict the High Courts.
#SupremeCourt #COVID19 #Oxygen
Supreme Court clarifies "The purpose of this court assuming jurisdiction suo moto under Article 32 is not to supplant or substitute the process of hearings undertaken by various High Courts to deal with issues related to pandemic".
#SupremeCourt #COVID19 #Oxygen
Bench is dictating the order now.
Justice Chandrachud asks Solicitor General to look into the applications filed by Grover and Dave.
#SupremeCourt #COVID19
Yatin Oza says that Gujarat Hospitals are insisting on coming in ambulances for admission. 108 if dialled will not respond before 24 hours. Newspapers have reported that patients have died because of this. Oza adds that Guj HC is looking at it.
#SupremeCourt #COVID19