I Won't Submit To Any Examination,Says Karnan.J, He Can’t Be Compulsorily Tested: Jaising [Read More Reactions]
story
A Seven Judge Constitution Bench of Supreme Court of India on Monday ordered the medical examination of Justice Karnan, who is facing contempt proceedings. The Bench has found that he is not in a position to defend him now.Reacting to this Justice Karnan has reportedly said;“Am I mentally unstable? Who is the Supreme Court to judge that I have a mental illness? The seven judges looking at...
Your free access to Live Law has expired
Please Subscribe for unlimited access to Live Law Archives, Weekly/Monthly Digest, Exclusive Notifications, Comments, Ad Free Version, Petition Copies, Judgement/Order Copies.
A Seven Judge Constitution Bench of Supreme Court of India on Monday ordered the medical examination of Justice Karnan, who is facing contempt proceedings. The Bench has found that he is not in a position to defend him now.
Reacting to this Justice Karnan has reportedly said;
“Am I mentally unstable? Who is the Supreme Court to judge that I have a mental illness? The seven judges looking at my case are corrupt,” he said at a press conference hours after the SC order.
“If the DGP acts against me without my consent, I will pass an order against him. He should stay within limits... I won't submit to any treatment,” News 18 reported him as saying.
Social Media Reactions
Senior Advocate Indira Jaising has tweeted that Mental Health Care Act 2017 requires informed consent to testing and treatment and Justice Karnan cannot be compulsorily tested by order of SC.
https://twitter.com/IJaising/status/859014090852679680
https://twitter.com/IJaising/status/859017308773076992
https://twitter.com/IJaising/status/859019121333125123
https://twitter.com/alokpi/status/858935105016008704
https://twitter.com/alokpi/status/858933486278803456
https://twitter.com/amitpai87/status/858930369936056320
https://twitter.com/gautambhatia88/status/858927962392940544
Will be updated...
Reacting to this Justice Karnan has reportedly said;
“Am I mentally unstable? Who is the Supreme Court to judge that I have a mental illness? The seven judges looking at my case are corrupt,” he said at a press conference hours after the SC order.
“If the DGP acts against me without my consent, I will pass an order against him. He should stay within limits... I won't submit to any treatment,” News 18 reported him as saying.
Social Media Reactions
Senior Advocate Indira Jaising has tweeted that Mental Health Care Act 2017 requires informed consent to testing and treatment and Justice Karnan cannot be compulsorily tested by order of SC.
https://twitter.com/IJaising/status/859014090852679680
https://twitter.com/IJaising/status/859017308773076992
https://twitter.com/IJaising/status/859019121333125123
https://twitter.com/alokpi/status/858935105016008704
https://twitter.com/alokpi/status/858933486278803456
https://twitter.com/amitpai87/status/858930369936056320
https://twitter.com/gautambhatia88/status/858927962392940544
Will be updated...