"As A Servant Of Constitution, I Have To Follow The Law Laid Down": CJI DY Chandrachud On Plea Against Collegium System

Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud said that as a "servant of the law and the Constitution", he has to follow the laid down law, when a lawyer mentioned a plea challenging the collegium system for judges' appointments.

Advocate Mathews J Nedumpara sought the listing of a petition filed by him seeking the abolition of the collegium system and a reevaluation of the process for designating senior advocates. However, the CJI did not seem to be inclined towards entertaining Nedumpara's request and said–

"As a lawyer, you have the freedom to pursue your heart's desire. But as a judge of this Court, I am a servant of the law and the Constitution. I have to follow the position and the law laid down." 

Nedumpara has  sought for a review of the 2015 NJAC verdict, arguing that the judgment should be rendered void ab initio. In 2015, the Supreme Court had struck down the National Judicial Appointments Commission(NJAC) and reaffirmed the collegium system,

When this matter was mentioned by him on a previous occasion for listing, CJI Chandrachud had wondered if a judgment could be challenged in a writ petition filed under Article 32.

According to the petitioner, the collegium system has failed and has resulted only in monopolising the higher judiciary by the kith and kin of sitting and former Judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, their juniors, celebrated lawyers. Earlier this years, the Supreme Court had dismissed a petition filed by him against the senior designation system.