Rajasthan High Court Issues Notice On Plea Against Denial Of Physical Hearing By NCLT Jaipur Bench

The Rajasthan High Court on Friday issued notice to the Jaipur Bench of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) while adjudicating upon an appeal against an order of the NCLT refusing the petitioner's request to allow physical hearing.

Justice Ashok Kumar Garg was apprised by the counsel appearing for the petitioner that the petitioner's application for seeking physical hearing of the case had been dismissed by the NCLT on the ground that there is no Standard Operating Procedure laid down for physical hearings with respect to the infrastructure and facilities available at the Jaipur bench of NCLT.

Furthermore, the petitioner submitted that the Supreme Court as well as different High Courts including Rajasthan High Court have already started the hybrid system of hearing matters either by physical mode or by virtual hearing.

It was also contended that since the proceedings before the Tribunal are at a final stage and the petitioner has every right to defend its case by referring to different documents, oral submissions vide physical hearing would be more effective. The counsel for the petitioner also referred to a circular dated July 1, 2021 issued by the Rajasthan High Court wherein directions had been given for the functioning of Subordinate Courts/Special Courts/Tribunals from July 5, 2021.

Taking cognisance of the grievance raised, the Court issued notice to the NCLT in the plea and directed that an additional copy be served on Additional Solicitor General RD Rastogi as well.

"Issue notice of the writ petition as well as stay application, returnable on December 21, 2021. Notices may be given 'dasti'. Additionally, a copy of writ petition be served in the office of Additional Solicitor General RD Rastogi, who represents the respondent No.2. His name be shown in the cause list", the Court directed.

The Court further stayed the proceedings before the NCLT till the next date of hearing.

"Till the next date, the National Company Law Tribunal, Jaipur Bench is restrained to proceed further in CP No.(IB)- 213/9/JPR/2020 under Section 9 of the IBC, 2016," the Court ordered.

Case Title: Dalas Biotech Ltd. v. Farmasino Pharmaceuticals

Click Here To Read/Download Order