Why Not Invoke Goonda Act Against Food Adulterers?: Madras High Court Orders Interim Ban On Sale Of Edible Oil As Loose Oil

The Bench of Justice N. Kirubakaran and Justice B. Pugalendhi was hearing a PIL filed by a practising Advocate seeking direction for the respondents to ensure that the edible oils sold in the market are in accordance with FSSAI standards and norms and for appropriate action as against the adulterators.

The matter before the Court

The Counsel representing the petitioner submitted that the edible oils available in the market are mostly adulterated and he also demonstrated as to how the adulterations are made.

He told the Court that by mixing a portion of Cashew Nut Shell Liquid (CNSL) in Palmolein, the Palmolein could be made equivalent to Gingelly Oil and the colour and odor will also match the same

He also informed the court that consuming CNSL (Cashew Nut Shell Liquid) would affect the nerve system and concentration ability, ie., would affect the Autonomic Nervous System (ANS) causing adverse effects, including, Blurring of vision, Nausea, Vomiting, Dizziness, Headache, Bradycardia (Decrease in Heart Rate) and Hypotension (Fall in Blood Pressure).

Importantly, it was informed to the Court that the re-use of Tin & Plastic containers for edible oils & fats is not allowed as per Food Safety and Standards (Packaging and Labelling) Regulations, 2011 prohibit

However, it was submitted, the proviso to rule 2.3.15 allows the State to exempt any oil from the application of this rule, by way of a gazette notification.

To this, the Bench observed that the food adulterers took advantage of this proviso as the State has permitted the sale of edible oil in loose packets without assigning reasons for it.

Court's Observations

The Court, in its order, said,

"The data placed before us is shocking that if an essential commodity like edible oil can be adulterated to this extent, we are afraid of the consequences on the health conditions of a common citizen."

The Court also remarked that Right to life is a fundamental right, guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution of India and right to have a healthy food is also one of the fundamental rights.

The Court further said,

"It is the duty of the Government to ensure that the people are getting healthy food without any adulteration. The very object behind the enactment of Prevention of Food Adulteration Act, 1954, now amended as Food Safety and Standards Act, 2006, is to enhance the quality standard and to ensure the availability of quality food for all citizens."

Importantly, the Court said,

"This Court is of the opinion that those who are involved in adulteration, ie., the adulterators, be it the Manufactures / Distributors / Sellers, should be termed as 'Goonda' as per the definition in Section 2 of the Tamil Nadu Act 14 of 1982, by amending the provisions to include them and should be detained under the Act 14 of 1982."

Considering the consequences of adulterated edible oils and the modes available for adulteration, the Court, among others, raised the following queries to be answered by the respondents 1 to 3 & 5:

• When the Food Safety and Standards (Prohibition and Restriction of Sales) Regulation, 2011, prohibits sale of edible oils on loose, how the edible oils are allowed to be sold as loose oils?
• What are all the consequences of these adulterations on the health conditions of the consumers?
• How many labs are available for testing in Tamil-nadu, both Government labs and Private labs and how many labs are available in other States (in tabulated version)?
• How many tests have been carried out in edible oils, throughout the State [District wise, for the past five years] and the results thereof and how many test reports resulted positive for the presence of CNSL, Peanut Essence and / or any other mixtures, if any?
• What is the action taken as against the adulterators / offenders?
• How many cases have been registered under the Act for the past five years, in the State and what is the conviction rate?
• Why not the State Government amend the Act 14 of 1982 to include "Food Adulterator" in the definition of "Goonda" and detain them under the Act, when food adulteration causes serious health hazards to the common people?

Case title - S. Arunnithy v. The CEO, FSSAI and others [WP(MD) No.18013 of 2020 and WMP(MD).No.15034 of 2020]

Click Here To Download Order