Dwivedi: 1. to be muslim is one thing and to be... ... Aligarh Muslim University Minority Status: Live Updates From Supreme Court Hearing [Day 6]

Dwivedi: 1. to be muslim is one thing and to be minority in another thing. eg- in Jammu and Kashmir, the majority are Muslims not minority its in that sense..the question would therefore be that either we proceed with the assumption which was made in A Basha that the Muslims in 1920 were a minority and decide whether they are entitled to the benefit of Article 30. Or we consider the question of facts if they were a minrity in 1920....the courts have proceeded on an assumption (even for Christian or Muslim colleges) that they were a minority) so how do we understand this concept minority? do we decide this today or gain as in TMA Pai it was said that theses questions be decided later