Sibal : therefore its a request please do not... ... Aligarh Muslim University Minority Status: Live Updates From Supreme Court Hearing [Day 8]

Sibal : therefore its a request please do not apply a test which may be constitutionally suspect. We are going wrong, because Basha was on the wrong footing

Sibal : the other thing ...the only fact in Basha is that because AMU is incorporated under the statute its not a minority. Thats the only fact... perhaps the 1981 Act takes away the basis of Basha

Sibal reads the letter written by Sir Syed Khand to Sir Elliot wrt ensuring the independence of the Institution although being under governmental supervision - what we understand by establishment is not the statutory form of establishment