J Bhat: Once you look at classes of horizontal... ... EWS Reservation- Supreme Court Constitution Bench Hearing- LIVE UPDATES

J Bhat: Once you look at classes of horizontal reservations, there is gender, disabilities, all of them intersect. That cannot happen in this. This is a clash.

CJI: The moment you say horizontally, it cannot be vertical.

J Bhat: The non obstante clause has to be read down